Oh, but it is a part of that universe.Quarto said:My dear Earthworm, if Academy TV was a part of the WC universe, then we seem to have a major continuity problem on our hands.
Hm, it's not the first WC product to contradict with something else.Furthermore,For one thing, when that happens, then the WC movie never existed- Blair keeps sending messages to his parents in Academy, while his parents are *dead* for quite a while in the movie.
But that would be a very stupid name.Of course. It's called WC: Priv. Curiously enough though, P2 is not called WC: Darkening...
No, not really.Care to explain why that amuses thee?
Various mentions of that in the novels...Where?
I'm going to humor you and say that I don't have much of an imagination. That doesn't change the fact that politicians can come up with some sh*ty stuff.I wouldn't call needing permision from Confed a real argument either. There could be milions of reasons for that.
Humour me. Name one.
How should I know? Maybe it made an unsuccessful jump and got puled into the Tre-systems?In that case, how did the Talon get there?
Because they won't to keep expanding their borders, and since they either think or know that people in Tri-systems are from Earth, therefore not natives of those systems they don't have any right to settle there.Also, why does Confed care if the Tri-Systemites settle another worthless planet?
Why do you compare everything to the past?Why, yes, I think I see your point... as a matter of fact, alcohol went out of use within a hundred years, right?And so did nicotine, right?And everything seems to indicate that Marijuana, Opium, and others will do the same, right?
Nope, I neaver heard of that.Did you know that they said that about Win95, and Win98?
Of course they would, but you'd have to do hell of a lot more things than you do during the game.Wait... you mean that in real life, they WOULDN'T use computers to make a pilot's life easier?
The frame is basicly the same, but it's a new model, that has replaced the first one in the 2640's. It has more missiles, and a better Neutron gun unlike the first one.Yeah, right. A good idea, with all those 50-year old carriers still floating around, right? But wait... didn't you say that the Rapier had been around for something like a 100 years before the Movie?
It certainly registered as unknown at the time the Kilrathi first encountered it, if they didn't have any captued schematics of Confed ships.Well, then I imagine it registers as an "unknown" on the Kilrathi screens. I guess they think that it's yet another alien race, coming to help the Terrans.
But neither do the 'burst missiles.Since when are the Cone/Starburst missiles exceedingly dangerous?
Since they contain non-standard, very powerful payloads, which do damage to all ships in a given area. A mine also does that... but then, a mine doesn't have a nuclear payload, right?
They must have little cargo space if you can tractor stuff in.Neither are any of the ships you get to fly in P2.
Which doesn't change the fact that they don't have cargo bays, and are right about the same size as P2's military fighters.
Including the pilot you tractor in?Who say's the cargoes go into the ship when tractored in? You're not usually required to take them very far. For all you know, they could just be strapped to the bottom of your vessel.
It says that they have big cargo bays, that could fit in some fighters if they were melted down...And how do you know that it's two/three times bigger? Do you think it 60-90 meters long?
I don't know how big they are exactly. But what I do know is that (tonnage-wise) you'd fit two Sabres, or four Ferrets in a Centurion's 50 ton cargo bay. In a Galaxy, even a Broadsword would fit. What does that say about their size?
Hm, I thought that even from the limited contact we have through this board you'd know me better than that.No, it's disappointing that you assume something like that.
Why, Earthworm, what choice do you leave me?
If that's your philosphy, than yes. All of the pilots we see in the FMV WC games also have secret cariears as actors.<sigh> Because nothing says that it does. If, "no proof" to you means that the statement is true, then I'd like to know why Blair didn't use his Jedi powers in any of the WCs. After all, he must have them, since there's no proof that he does, right?
Yes they did.Of course they did.
No, they didn't.
Hm, that's nice. I don't see how you can argue that the technology we see in P2, 100 years after the most recent SP WC game, would have to be the same as it was in that last game in the main series. And just because DH agrees with you, and maybe some other people, doesn't mean that *everyone* agrees with them.In other words, don't be silly. There is absolutely nothing in P2 that would indicate any relationship with Confed. Now, so far I've given plenty of good reasons (or at least reasons that everyone but you consider good enough) as to why that is the case. All you've provided in return is a number of weak arguments that seemingly defy all logic known to mankind.
Aye, but it's very talented at contradictingEW Says:
Hm, it's not the first WC product to contradict with something else.
Would it? No. If you hadn't heard of P2: The Darkening, then WC: The Darkening would seem perfectly natural.But that would be a very stupid name.
Where?Various mentions of that in the novels...
Even if that was true, I hardly think Confed has a better claim on Tri-Sys than the Tri-Systemites.Because they won't to keep expanding their borders, and since they either think or know that people in Tri-systems are from Earth, therefore not natives of those systems they don't have any right to settle there.
Surely, that should be obvious? If that's the way things happened in the past, what makes you think they'll happen differently in the future? History repeats itself.Why do you compare everything to the past?
Manually searching through the ship database to identify the ship not being one of those things...Of course they would, but you'd have to do hell of a lot more things than you do during the game.
So why wouldn't the same thing happen to the Talon?The frame is basicly the same, but it's a new model, that has replaced the first one in the 2640's. It has more missiles, and a better Neutron gun unlike the first one.
Sorry, I can't resist using one of your favourite arguments - how do you know that?But neither do the 'burst missiles.
It certainly is, because the pilot is already wearing a vac-suit. But another possibility is that it's like a Broadsword - room enough for a pilot, or maybe a tiny datapod, but no room for cargo. Of course, Broadswords don't have the capability to strap cargo to their underside, but I don't see why privateering vessels wouldn't have such capabilities, since it's very advantageous.Including the pilot you tractor in?It is possible....
Exactly. Which means that they must be bigger than the P2 ships, without big cargo bays.It says that they have big cargo bays, that could fit in some fighters if they were melted down...
Oh, I know you well enoughHm, I thought that even from the limited contact we have through this board you'd know me better than that.
No, they didn't.Of course they did.
No, they didn't.
Yes they did.
First of all, I'm not saying that. I'm merely arguing that you can't argue that the technology in P2 is related to WC technology. Second, when I said "everybody" I meant everybody involved in the discussion, not actually everybody.Hm, that's nice. I don't see how you can argue that the technology we see in P2, 100 years after the most recent SP WC game, would have to be the same as it was in that last game in the main series. And just because DH agrees with you, and maybe some other people, doesn't mean that *everyone* agrees with them.
Does Confed actualy learn what that ceremony is for in Academy?Quarto said:But what about the Sivar-Eshrad ceremony? That also happens in both WCA and WC1, and both times, Confed doesn't know what the hell is happening.
Actualy, with all the alliances, Confed is larger than the Kilrathi, who conquer most of the races they encounter.And as for the Kilrathi being more common... they are. Not because we fight them, but because they've got an Empire twice the size of the Confederation.
True, but it still has some prety good stuff that doesn't contradict anything.Aye, but it's very talented at contradicting.
Maybe.... but it just doesn't sound right.Would it? No. If you hadn't heard of P2: The Darkening, then WC: The Darkening would seem perfectly natural.
In one the many novels in which the Landreich is presentVarious mentions of that in the novels...
Where?
Of course, but if you try to settle on an island somewhere on the international waters, and claim it as your country, no one would take you seriously, and everyone could go there.Even if that was true, I hardly think Confed has a better claim on Tri-Sys than the Tri-Systemites.
Of course, but new things happen too.Surely, that should be obvious? If that's the way things happened in the past, what makes you think they'll happen differently in the future? History repeats itself.
No, but for example, telling your computer in what era, or type of ships to look for.Manually searching through the ship database to identify the ship not being one of those things...
Why wouldn't what happen? Upgrade the Talon? You'd have to be insane to even think of something like that.So why wouldn't the same thing happen to the Talon?
Because no one would need a nuke to blast open the casing of the missile and shoot out the little bullets.But neither do the 'burst missiles.
Sorry, I can't resist using one of your favourite arguments - how do you know that?
But those cargo bays don't certainly have to be so big as to make the fighters that much larger. True, they are most likely larger than P2 fighters, but not neccissarly ships like the 'bow or a T-bolt.Exactly. Which means that they must be bigger than the P2 ships, without big cargo bays.
Actualy, having not played any WC game in few months, and having not read any manuals except the P2 one, for even more time, I did forget it (you should know how it is. Two or three months of school left, a man has to start workingOh, I know you well enough. And I assumed that you wouldn't make such a silly mistake by accident, so it must have been done on purpose.
Like my friend Mark Asher would say: You're in denial Quarto.No, they didn't.
I'm not arguing that it is, but you definetly can't argue that it isn't.First of all, I'm not saying that. I'm merely arguing that you can't argue that the technology in P2 is related to WC technology.
So.... that would make DH and you?Second, when I said "everybody" I meant everybody involved in the discussion, not actually everybody.
Yeah, they do. Hob... er... I mean, the Kilrathi defectorDoes Confed actualy learn what that ceremony is for in Academy?
I don't know... it doesn't seem that way. But there's no way of proving either side, so I'll just let it lie.Actualy, with all the alliances, Confed is larger than the Kilrathi, who conquer most of the races they encounter.
Oui, but of courseTrue, but it still has some prety good stuff that doesn't contradict anything.
Hmm... I don't recall anything like that in FA... maybe it's in FC.In one the many novels in which the Landreich is present either FA, or FC.
Oh? Then why did I need a visa to get to Australia?Of course, but if you try to settle on an island somewhere on the international waters, and claim it as your country, no one would take you seriously, and everyone could go there.
Not exactly. It's the same old things, but in different ways. A pity, that. At any rate, trust me. History is one of the things that I do know aboutOf course, but new things happen too.
Hmm... maybe. But that's on a shipboard computer. I would think that the bigger databases (like CIS') would automatically do a search on all vessel types. Just seems logical, to me. For one thing, there is always the possibility of bumping into the VoyagersNo, but for example, telling your computer in what era, or type of ships to look for.
Why, Earthworm... I mean, I know the Talon sucks, but...Why wouldn't what happen? Upgrade the Talon? You'd have to be insane to even think of something like that.
<Grin> I know. So, I was wrong.Because no one would need a nuke to blast open the casing of the missile and shoot out the little bullets.
Well, some of the P2 ships look awfully small. Take the Straith, for example. And yet, it's the slowest ship around... you'd think it would at least have the option of an engine upgrade.But those cargo bays don't certainly have to be so big as to make the fighters that much larger. True, they are most likely larger than P2 fighters, but not neccissarly ships like the 'bow or a T-bolt.
Then I excuse youActualy, having not played any WC game in few months, and having not read any manuals except the P2 one, for even more time, I did forget it (you should know how it is. Two or three months of school left, a man has to start working).
Because you're special.Quarto said:Of course, but if you try to settle on an island somewhere on the international waters, and claim it as your country, no one would take you seriously, and everyone could go there.
Oh? Then why did I need a visa to get to Australia?
But the old things had to be new sometime. So, new things did happen.Of course, but new things happen too.
Not exactly. It's the same old things, but in different ways. A pity, that. At any rate, trust me. History is one of the things that I do know about.
True.... maybe the CIS doesn't want us to know about the Talon? It's a conspiracy!Hmm... maybe. But that's on a shipboard computer. I would think that the bigger databases (like CIS') would automatically do a search on all vessel types.
There are no buts! The Talon is a piece of crap and it should die in hell!Why, Earthworm... I mean, I know the Talon sucks, but...
It could be so slow because it's so cheap.Well, some of the P2 ships look awfully small. Take the Straith, for example. And yet, it's the slowest ship around... you'd think it would at least have the option of an engine upgrade.
Why, thank you.Then I excuse you.
Other than being able to see through cloack of course.Anyway, I think that the Confed cloaks probably still require some expensive substance to fuel them, or something like that. At least, that would seem to be the most logical reason as to why it's in limited use.
Yeah... 'bout ten thousand years ago...But the old things had to be new sometime. So, new things did happen.
Yeah, but then wouldn't there be an engine upgrade? At any rate, it's rather odd that in P2, light fighters are the slowest and least manoeuvrable. But that's a topic for another debateIt could be so slow because it's so cheap.
Hmm, well, that wouldn't affect things much. I mean, Confed wouldn't suddenly scrap all their cloaking devices just because the bugs can see through them (which we're still not sure about).Other than being able to see through cloack of course.
Yup, just like flight and space travel….Quarto said:But the old things had to be new sometime. So, new things did happen.
Yeah... 'bout ten thousand years ago...
Not if it’s build for people so poor that they wouldn’t be able to afford one. And it is.Yeah, but then wouldn't there be an engine upgrade?
But isn’t that the case with Priv too? The Centurion is the heaviest fighter, and it’s the fastest.At any rate, it's rather odd that in P2, light fighters are the slowest and least manoeuvrable. But that's a topic for another debate.
Hmm, well, that wouldn't affect things much. I mean, Confed wouldn't suddenly scrap all their cloaking devices just because the bugs can see through them (which we're still not sure about).
Tsk, tsk. History is not about individual events, or about technology. It's about people. And as far as people are concerned, flight and space travel had the same effects on them as ships, and trans-oceanic voyages did. Armstrong walking on the moon could very well have been Columbus walking on the shores of Haiti (or whatever the place he landed on first was). You see, the "human factor" is the one thing that remains constant, no matter how much our technology changes. People in six hundred years will be no different to us - they'll simply use different technology.Yup, just like flight and space travel...
Strictly speaking, if you buy a Straith, then you're definitely not poor... you're just not exceptionally richNot if it’s build for people so poor that they wouldn’t be able to afford one. And it is.
Nope. The Orion is the heaviest fighter. The Tarsus is an ancient (inherited from your grandfatherBut isn’t that the case with Priv too? The Centurion is the heaviest fighter, and it’s the fastest.
I don't think the detecting technology is all that popular. As with cloaking technology, Confed has probably been keeping it to itself.Ah, but who says it’s because of the bugs? If the small reminder of the black lance (of course, they are gone now), pirates, Kilrathi, and whatever else there is would be able to see through it without much problems, than it wouldn’t be used as often by the Prophecy time.
Mostly true....Quarto said:Tsk, tsk. History is not about individual events, or about technology. It's about people. And as far as people are concerned, flight and space travel had the same effects on them as ships, and trans-oceanic voyages did. Armstrong walking on the moon could very well have been Columbus walking on the shores of Haiti (or whatever the place he landed on first was). You see, the "human factor" is the one thing that remains constant, no matter how much our technology changes. People in six hundred years will be no different to us - they'll simply use different technology.
Well, you are poor for a Privateer......Strictly speaking, if you buy a Straith, then you're definitely not poor... you're just not exceptionally rich.
Doesn't the Centurion have the heaviest armor of them all? Anyhow, the Centurion has more gun mounts, space for two missile launchers instead of one on the Tarsus.... And the Galaxy is as much of a fighter as the Centurion.Nope. The Orion is the heaviest fighter. The Tarsus is an ancient (inherited from your grandfather) scout ship, and the Galaxy is a small freighter. Thus, it's only natural that the Centurion is the fastest.
But Confed isn't the only faction with smart people.I don't think the detecting technology is all that popular. As with cloaking technology, Confed has probably been keeping it to itself.
Ah, but I didn't say that that was how much privateers normally have.Well, you are poor for a Privateer......
'Sbeen a long time since I've played Priv, but I believe that the Orion has the heaviest everything. And as for the Tarsus and Galaxy - like I said, the Tarsus is fairly old. Probably twenty, maybe thirty or forty years old. And the Galaxy is classified as a merchant ship, I believe. Furthermore, it's got quite a bit more space onboard than the Centurion. It has every right to be slowerDoesn't the Centurion have the heaviest armor of them all? Anyhow, the Centurion has more gun mounts, space for two missile launchers instead of one on the Tarsus.... And the Galaxy is as much of a fighter as the Centurion.
I dinna say they were, and I dinna say they couldn'tBut Confed isn't the only faction with smart people. Hunter, while flying for the Landreich, was able to find a Strakha using nothing more than the standard equipment from his fighter. And the Kilrathi where first to have a cloack, so it wouldn't be surprising if they had something to see through cloack even earlier than Confed.
And who here said that BL and pirates had that ability?Death's Head said:The BL forces could see cloaked ships because they themselves were cloaked, or they were allowed to see because the cloak had some function that enabled you to do so. You could not see cloaked ships in WC4 if you didn't have a cloak yourself.
Where were pirates able to see through cloaks?
Actualy, the cloack got them to Kilrath. By the time they entered the atmosphere, they had to decloack. Second, no one said that they did have it, at least at that time. Third, if they did have that ability they would still have to be relatively near the Excals.When were the Kilrathi able to see through cloaks? If they could see, why did they not dispatch large fighter groups to deal with them in Kilrah? If Blair hadn't cloaked on the last leg of his route, there would have been no way he could have gotten though, in fact I think there wasn't, even in the game.
Why is that? The cloack isn't a standard equipment on the Excals. And why exactly would all other pilots be sent in Piranhas while Major Washington flew an Excal?The recon ships sent against the bugs could have been Piranhas for all we know, it was a Major that flew an Excalibur in, which makes sense if it had a cloak.
There are so many things that are wrong with that comment.Incidentally, that ship wasn't detected.
Hmm, well technically, only Lt. Shea had to fly the same ship as Major Washington. The others were all from a different squadron. And as to Lt. Shea's disappearance, she could have been taken by surprise, before activating her cloak.Why is that? The cloack isn't a standard equipment on the Excals. And why exactly would all other pilots be sent in Piranhas while Major Washington flew an Excal?
Well, while it's true that Major Washington failed to spot any live enemies, the basic statement remains trueThere are so many things that are wrong with that comment.
But the first squadron was also a Long-Range-Patrol squadron. I don't see why they wouldn't fly a fighter that is much better for long range recon than most fighters at the time. Including the Piranha.Quarto said:Hmm, well technically, only Lt. Shea had to fly the same ship as Major Washington. The others were all from a different squadron. And as to Lt. Shea's disappearance, she could have been taken by surprise, before activating her cloak.
Um, I know... Just using the fighter he gave as an example.Oh, and DH doesn't say that they were Piranhas - just that as far as we know, they could even be Piranhas. See, that's what I mean about reading a post carefully.
That is unknown. Maybe the bugs wanted someone to escape for whatever reason. And just because the first 6 patrols were destroyed doesn't mean they didn't cary cloacks. Those fighters would have to decloack sometime.Well, while it's true that Major Washington failed to spot any live enemies, the basic statement remains true. He wasn't detected.
Well, I hope they don't fly PiranhasBut the first squadron was also a Long-Range-Patrol squadron. I don't see why they wouldn't fly a fighter that is much better for long range recon than most fighters at the time. Including the Piranha.
<Shrug> Sure, why not. As long as you acknowledge that there is a distinct possibility that the Bugs don't see through cloakThat is unknown. Maybe the bugs wanted someone to escape for whatever reason. And just because the first 6 patrols were destroyed doesn't mean they didn't cary cloacks. Those fighters would have to decloack sometime.
Ah, but an Excal is larger. Major Washington’s Excal was armed only with lasers because they had to put so much equipment on it. The Vampire is slightly longer than one half of an Excal.Quarto said:Well, I hope they don't fly Piranhas. But what makes you think the Excalibur is better than most others? A well out-fitted Panther could easily do better. And a Vampire... no comment.
Of course there is.<Shrug> Sure, why not. As long as you acknowledge that there is a distinct possibility that the Bugs don't see through cloak.