Bandit LOAF
Long Live the Confederation!
I guess I just don't see the connection between a fan project like WC Saga and the Freespace fan group.
Wing Commander fans shouldn't like Freespace. Freespace helped kill Wing Commander - we should *never* be obligated to pay lip service to something with that legacy. It's important for us to remember what happened in the late nineties because someday we'll get another shot, and when we do we need to make damn sure that the world understands that the general population recognizes the difference between Wing Commander and generic trash. To decide now to look back on Freespace 2 as some sort of gaming holy grail is counterproductive to that goal - it was a bad game that sold badly for good reasons. Remembering that, ultimately, is what will preserve Wing Commander.
Now, if you guys can take Freespace and make it into something fun for Wing Commander fans, then fantastic. We'll salute the hell out of you - but Wing Commander Saga being great isn't the same thing as Freespace being great.
(And yes, I do feel genuinely bad for the Freespace fans with regards to the Derek Smart situation. The whole thing is funny in that it's a terrible farce... but ultimately Derek Smart is both a bad developer and a community killer. Ask anyone who survived csipgss... if you can find any of us still willing to touch space sims. The fans, however misguided I believe their affections to be, don't deserve our scorn. I hate Freespace, not Freespace fans.)
(Furthermore, all of this is neither here nor there - we have friendly jokes with all the other space sim groups (and we take just as many shots at ourselves)... it's only the Freespace people who feel the need to take it personally. That's an indication of something on their part, not ours.)
Wing Commander fans shouldn't like Freespace. Freespace helped kill Wing Commander - we should *never* be obligated to pay lip service to something with that legacy. It's important for us to remember what happened in the late nineties because someday we'll get another shot, and when we do we need to make damn sure that the world understands that the general population recognizes the difference between Wing Commander and generic trash. To decide now to look back on Freespace 2 as some sort of gaming holy grail is counterproductive to that goal - it was a bad game that sold badly for good reasons. Remembering that, ultimately, is what will preserve Wing Commander.
Now, if you guys can take Freespace and make it into something fun for Wing Commander fans, then fantastic. We'll salute the hell out of you - but Wing Commander Saga being great isn't the same thing as Freespace being great.
(And yes, I do feel genuinely bad for the Freespace fans with regards to the Derek Smart situation. The whole thing is funny in that it's a terrible farce... but ultimately Derek Smart is both a bad developer and a community killer. Ask anyone who survived csipgss... if you can find any of us still willing to touch space sims. The fans, however misguided I believe their affections to be, don't deserve our scorn. I hate Freespace, not Freespace fans.)
(Furthermore, all of this is neither here nor there - we have friendly jokes with all the other space sim groups (and we take just as many shots at ourselves)... it's only the Freespace people who feel the need to take it personally. That's an indication of something on their part, not ours.)