Talk:First Battle of Kilrah - 2667: Difference between revisions

The Terran Knowledge Bank
Jump to: navigation, search
m (moved Talk:Raid on Kilrah to Talk:KIlrah Raid - Strike Force Valkyrie - 2667: Per LOAF and my conversation in #wingnut. See talk page.)
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
This does need to be totally redone. Writing is poor, facts are wrong and it oversteps its bounds by trying to relate the withdrawal of the Tarawa and Intrepid from Kilrah.
Personally, I'd recommend a rewrite from scratch by someone more familiar with the material.
- Dundradal
Maybe it's time that I correct the flaws in this article. I realize it has a lot of reworking that needs to be done. Question: Should we change the title to "Raid of Kilrah" or something? I know this was officially classified as a raid rather than a battle. (Not much of a difference, but regardless, what sounds more appropriate?) -Aeronautico
Maybe it's time that I correct the flaws in this article. I realize it has a lot of reworking that needs to be done. Question: Should we change the title to "Raid of Kilrah" or something? I know this was officially classified as a raid rather than a battle. (Not much of a difference, but regardless, what sounds more appropriate?) -Aeronautico


Line 15: Line 8:




I reviewed this one already, and only did some basic rephrasing. What sort of direction did you want for the article, it doesn't seem that bad to me? - Wedge
Per LOAF and my conversation on #wingnut. We were talking about the name of this inuniverse when we really couldn't find on specific name. We then started talking about a standard for un-named battles.
 
Removed fact-check tag, as per #wingnut discussion. - Wedge

Revision as of 00:13, 22 August 2010

Maybe it's time that I correct the flaws in this article. I realize it has a lot of reworking that needs to be done. Question: Should we change the title to "Raid of Kilrah" or something? I know this was officially classified as a raid rather than a battle. (Not much of a difference, but regardless, what sounds more appropriate?) -Aeronautico

I've been referencing this article as Raid on Kilrah in my edits. I don't know why it's titled like this. The thing in question is repeatedly and often referred to as the "Kilrah raid". - Bob 10:39, 21 August 2010 (CDT)
I concur. Will move in a few minutes unless anyone objects? - Wedge
Done. - Wedge


Per LOAF and my conversation on #wingnut. We were talking about the name of this inuniverse when we really couldn't find on specific name. We then started talking about a standard for un-named battles.

Retrieved from "https://www.wcnews.com/wcpedia/index.php?title=Talk:First_Battle_of_Kilrah_-_2667&oldid=11653"