MiniReview: The Confederation Handbook Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Update ID

Well, after it didn't come from B&N on time an exciting trek into our nation's capitol located me a copy of the Wing Commander Confederation Handbook... here's what I thought! (Be warned, this review may contain SPOILERS).

The Good: Ask anybody, they'll tell you that one of the coolest things about Wing Commander has always been the cool in-depth manuals - WC1 had it's Claw Marks, WC3 had Victory Streak and so on. The Confederation Handbook is essentially a manual for the Wing Commander Movie - and it's got to be the most beautiful manual ever. Full of color and wonderful graphics, this book does an excellent job of explaining a lot of things WC fans have been wondering about: the pre-war history, the ships of the movie, character backgrounds, etc. The format is great, designed as if someone were browsing an online service (complete with banner ads). It also has all the stuff fans of the more popular sci fi series' have grown accustomed to: deck plans, nose art, scientific papers explaining the history and principles of jump technology -- basically any cool stuff they could cram into it.

The Bad: You may or may not be familiar with the fact that I'm a stickler for continuity (also, an inside joke). This book at times either delights me or infuriates me. It has the most obscure references, and then it changes some of the most obvious. For example, a letter from Blair's Academy instructor to the XO of the Tiger's Claw actually mentions the events from Red & Blue [Ed: the first Wing Commander Academy episode]... but then the book changes the date of the beggining of the Kilrathi war by some nine years. Its ship specifications are also a bit odd - while Peter Telep's WC novel stuck to the traditional WC specs (for the Concordia, for instance), the handbook creates new ones. It's actually not that bad, though, and shouldn't ruin your enjoyment of the book - hell, after a long chat with Crid last night, I'm all ready to explain all the changes during the sure-to-follow arguments in agwc.

Extra: What else could it possibly have? One odd note - why is it that the only pilot who's fighter has a scantily clad woman painted on its nose is Angel? You have to wonder...

MiniReview: Wing Commander Junior Novelization Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Update ID

I did, however, get my copy of the Wing Commander Junior Novelization from B&N. Here's what is sure to me my standard nifty review format...

The Good: It's the same as the excellent Wing Commander Adaptation... only younger! Some of the details (and all of the sex) have been cut to make it suitable for a younger audience, and I can see giving it to my little sister to read in a few years. Right now, however, I enjoyed reading it, and the fact that it has nice larger print (and bigger pages) is a godsend...

The Bad: I'd complain about the lack of sex, but that'd be hypocritical. Actually, we should start campaigning to get it on middle school reading lists or something, so as to create converts. Honestly, nothing bad. I think it still calls Bossman Vince instead of Kien, but all the movie products seem to do that...

Extra: Same 8 page photo suppliment, HarperCollins has gone all out lavishing all three WC movie books with such treatment. It doesn't have the bonus chapter of the WC movie book (presumably the second book won't have a Junior counterpart), but it does have one interesting bonus: the list of books in the front lists "Wing Commander Book 1" and "Wing Commander Book 2" as 'coming soon'.


Recent Updates


Follow or Contact Us

All Wings Considered

Episode 37 - Back to Gemini!
Archived video streams

Forums: Recent Posts

  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

Current Poll

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Where to Buy

WCPedia: Recent Contributions

  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

Site Staff